Originally posted by sf1giantfan:
I believe this spring training, if he is still with us will be the breaking point. I mean, if he can be used in a trade to bring a player with some OBP smarts, then maybe. But, remember the hitting coach we brought up, is the same guy who helped bowker get his act together, and the results were quite good. I don't mean the tiny part time sample in the majors, but his triple -A numbers. Hopefully he can guide him well in ST, and he can be the next Will Clark (hitting), and not the next todd linden.
And, yes, I know bochy has a good chance of preventing bowker and our other young guys from succeeding, but maybe, just maybe he break through, even with bochy managing.
I see Bowker being on the 25 man after spring training. Rowand, Velez, Nate, and perhaps Freddy will be the 5th.
Obviously he is at the top of the PCL and it's time to prove hes a ML'er or a 4-A player. The problem with the Giants and there younger players is pointed out above in this thread by the memtion that other than Sandoval who has 1+ year under his belt and now Sanchez there are NO proven major leauge hitters on the current roster.
Rent and Rowand were embrassments all 2nd half as they dueled each other for the 8 spot in the order. THOSE are the vetrans you are building around here. They are more holes in the order than competent, and grossly overpaid for their "production".
Putting Bowker in a lineup that includes those guys would be weakening his protection, and asking him to produce the inflated power numbers of the PCL at ATT against a diet of Major League pitching is like throwing the 5 year old in the deep end.
Asking him to be Will Clark is great in Spring but remember Ishikawa lead the team in HR's last year and how did that work out? To my eyes Sandoval is the ONLY thing MLB worthy in the projected starting line-up as of today. Without another proven commodity around him pitchers will pick apart guys like Bowker and the rest and Panda will get to flail at garbage at get more semi-intentional passes than Barry ever did.